Welcome to Codidact Meta!
Codidact Meta is the meta-discussion site for the Codidact community network and the Codidact software. Whether you have bug reports or feature requests, support questions or rule discussions that touch the whole network – this is the site for you.
Comments on Show more threaded comments after clicking the title of a threaded discussion
Parent
Show more threaded comments after clicking the title of a threaded discussion
After clicking on the title of a threaded discussion, a user can read up to five threaded comments; if a user wants to read more, clicking "see the whole thread" is needed.
- I think 5 is too little and showing up to 10 threaded comments without clicking "see the whole thread" would be better
- It might be best to just show all threaded comments right after clicking the title because in general threaded discussions shouldn't pass the 15-20 comments (I guess)
I agree that someone who asks for the comments should see the comments, especially with the "collapse" control. Very …
3y ago
I agree that showing just the first five comments is a little on the low end in many cases. I don't think blindly inc …
3y ago
I agree. Once I've said I want to see the thread, show me the thread. Systems that try to automatically do something …
3y ago
Post
I agree that someone who asks for the comments should see the comments, especially with the "collapse" control.
Very occasionally here (so far; this happened often on some sites Someplace Else), there will be a very long comment thread, by which I mean 20+. Over there we sometimes saw 100+ comments on a post. This led us to think about a middle ground -- show the first five and make it easy to get to the rest.
"Get to the rest" still involves going to a separate page, though, which is not ideal if you need other context on the page (other comment threads or answers). Would it be better to still show the first N (maybe 5 is the wrong N; that can be changed if so) and then have a "show rest" control that loads them right there on the page? We still want the separate thread page for certain linking scenarios, but it seems that most people want to interact with comments right there on the page, and we should make that easier. The question is: all at once, even if that's a firehose, or a progressive approach that still requires a second click but doesn't make you go to another page?
Somebody is working on a change for better in-page comments right now, so this is a great time to weigh in on this question.
0 comment threads