Communities

The Great Outdoors

Photography & Video

Scientific Speculation

Electrical Engineering

Languages & Linguistics

Software Development

Community Proposals

tag:snake search within a tag

answers:0 unanswered questions

user:xxxx search by author id

score:0.5 posts with 0.5+ score

"snake oil" exact phrase

votes:4 posts with 4+ votes

created:<1w created < 1 week ago

post_type:xxxx type of post

Notifications

Mark all as read See all your notifications »

Q&A

Posts Tags Edits

Welcome to Codidact Meta!

Codidact Meta is the meta-discussion site for the Codidact community network and the Codidact software. Whether you have bug reports or feature requests, support questions or rule discussions that touch the whole network – this is the site for you.

Comments on Show more threaded comments after clicking the title of a threaded discussion

Parent

Show more threaded comments after clicking the title of a threaded discussion

+7

−1

After clicking on the title of a threaded discussion, a user can read up to five threaded comments; if a user wants to read more, clicking "see the whole thread" is needed.

I think 5 is too little and showing up to 10 threaded comments without clicking "see the whole thread" would be better
It might be best to just show all threaded comments right after clicking the title because in general threaded discussions shouldn't pass the 15-20 comments (I guess)

discussion design user-experience threads

posted about 3 years ago

CC BY-SA 4.0

3y ago by Moshi‭

deleted user

Raw

Markdown

is a duplicate

This question has been asked before and has already been answered. It should be marked as a duplicate.

Please enter the URL of the proposed duplicate in the details field below.

not constructive

This question cannot be answered in a way that is helpful to anyone. It's not possible to learn something from possible answers, except for the solution for the specific problem of the asker.

I agree that someone who asks for the comments should see the comments, especially with the "collapse" control. Very …

3y ago

I agree that showing just the first five comments is a little on the low end in many cases. I don't think blindly inc …

3y ago

I agree. Once I've said I want to see the thread, show me the thread. Systems that try to automatically do something …

3y ago

0 comment threads

Post

+3

−0

I agree that someone who asks for the comments should see the comments, especially with the "collapse" control.

Very occasionally here (so far; this happened often on some sites Someplace Else), there will be a very long comment thread, by which I mean 20+. Over there we sometimes saw 100+ comments on a post. This led us to think about a middle ground -- show the first five and make it easy to get to the rest.

"Get to the rest" still involves going to a separate page, though, which is not ideal if you need other context on the page (other comment threads or answers). Would it be better to still show the first N (maybe 5 is the wrong N; that can be changed if so) and then have a "show rest" control that loads them right there on the page? We still want the separate thread page for certain linking scenarios, but it seems that most people want to interact with comments right there on the page, and we should make that easier. The question is: all at once, even if that's a firehose, or a progressive approach that still requires a second click but doesn't make you go to another page?

Somebody is working on a change for better in-page comments right now, so this is a great time to weigh in on this question.

posted about 3 years ago

CC BY-SA 4.0

Monica Cellio‭ staff

64 372 2259 828

Copy Link

Raw

Markdown

1 comment thread

I personally tend to think that it would be best to show all comments, if indeed in general, people w... (6 comments)

deleted user wrote about 3 years ago

I personally tend to think that it would be best to show all comments, if indeed in general, people won't pass the 15-20 comments per thread ; a possible way to ensure that threads stay in in plausible longevities (and to add more website dynamicity) might be similar to what's going on in SitePoint (great community by the way) where threads are automatically locked three months after the last reply.

elgonzo‭ wrote about 3 years ago · edited about 3 years ago

In my opinion whether to auto-expand all comments or not could be a user settings. Implementation-wise, this should not be much of a difference - in one case, the function to expand is being invoked by a click handler, in the other case, the same expand function is invoked by some other JS script/function that runs after page load...

celtschk‭ wrote about 3 years ago

What about making the threshold at 10 comments? I think that should be sufficient for most comment threads to be completely inline.

However there are three things I'd like changed, no matter where the threshold is:

If the number of comments is just one over the threshold, they should still be shown inline, because having to click for merely a single comment sucks. Probably also for two past the threshold. That way, you'd get at least three extra comments when clicking the comment page.
If all comments of a comment thread are shown inline, you should also be able to respond inline, instead of having to go to the comments page. Maybe with a reply button at the bottom (which would disappear if not all comments are shown).
The post the comments are referring to should be shown also on the separate comment page.