Welcome to Codidact Meta!
Codidact Meta is the meta-discussion site for the Codidact community network and the Codidact software. Whether you have bug reports or feature requests, support questions or rule discussions that touch the whole network – this is the site for you.
Post History
We've got a category for meta posts on the electrical engineering (EE) vsite. I've noticed that votes on my posts in the meta reflect in my reputation on the EE site. The votes on a local meta-EE...
#5: Post edited
by
ArtOfCode
·
2020-11-02T03:26:45Z (over 3 years ago)
#4: Post edited
by
Nick Alexeev
·
2020-11-02T02:15:04Z (over 3 years ago)
- We've got a [category for meta posts on the electrical engineering (EE) vsite](https://electrical.codidact.com/categories/27). I've noticed that votes on my posts in the meta reflect in my reputation on the EE site. The votes on a local meta-EE shouldn't reflect on the reputation on EE. This looks like a bug (or a lack of feature), or a missing configuration.
**edit:**> Why shouldn't they be the same rep, it is the same site?[from comments]- Reputation should reflect what somebody knows about the subject matter of the site. If the upvotes in a meta count towards subject matter reputation, then it becomes easy to abuse the meta. If somebody wants cheap reputation, one can say something very popular along the lines of “free bread and circuses”, or just tell a joke, and get upvotes. But that doesn’t reflect his expertise in the subject matter, or his willingness to write quality Q&A. Meta shouldn't count towards reputation. The Old Republic SE got that one right.
- We've got a [category for meta posts on the electrical engineering (EE) vsite](https://electrical.codidact.com/categories/27). I've noticed that votes on my posts in the meta reflect in my reputation on the EE site. The votes on a local meta-EE shouldn't reflect on the reputation on EE. This looks like a bug (or a lack of feature), or a missing configuration.
- Reputation should reflect what somebody knows about the subject matter of the site. If the upvotes in a meta count towards subject matter reputation, then it becomes easy to abuse the meta. If somebody wants cheap reputation, one can say something very popular along the lines of “free bread and circuses”, or just tell a joke, and get upvotes. But that doesn’t reflect his expertise in the subject matter, or his willingness to write quality Q&A. Meta shouldn't count towards reputation. The Old Republic SE got that one right.
#3: Post edited
by
Nick Alexeev
·
2020-11-02T02:10:34Z (over 3 years ago)
We've got a [category for meta posts on the electrical engineering (EE) vsite](https://electrical.codidact.com/categories/27). I've noticed that votes on my posts in the meta reflect in my reputation on the EE site. The votes on a local meta-EE shouldn't reflect on the reputation on EE. This looks like a bug (or a lack of feature), or a missing configuration.
- We've got a [category for meta posts on the electrical engineering (EE) vsite](https://electrical.codidact.com/categories/27). I've noticed that votes on my posts in the meta reflect in my reputation on the EE site. The votes on a local meta-EE shouldn't reflect on the reputation on EE. This looks like a bug (or a lack of feature), or a missing configuration.
- **edit:**
- > Why shouldn't they be the same rep, it is the same site?
- [from comments]
- Reputation should reflect what somebody knows about the subject matter of the site. If the upvotes in a meta count towards subject matter reputation, then it becomes easy to abuse the meta. If somebody wants cheap reputation, one can say something very popular along the lines of “free bread and circuses”, or just tell a joke, and get upvotes. But that doesn’t reflect his expertise in the subject matter, or his willingness to write quality Q&A. Meta shouldn't count towards reputation. The Old Republic SE got that one right.
#2: Post edited
by
Nick Alexeev
·
2020-11-02T01:52:26Z (over 3 years ago)
A vote in a meta category reflected in my reputation. Is something missing?
- A vote in the meta category for the EE site reflected in my reputation. Is that a bug?
#1: Initial revision
by
Nick Alexeev
·
2020-11-02T01:49:53Z (over 3 years ago)
A vote in a meta category reflected in my reputation. Is something missing?
We've got a [category for meta posts on the electrical engineering (EE) vsite](https://electrical.codidact.com/categories/27). I've noticed that votes on my posts in the meta reflect in my reputation on the EE site. The votes on a local meta-EE shouldn't reflect on the reputation on EE. This looks like a bug (or a lack of feature), or a missing configuration.