Welcome to Codidact Meta!
Codidact Meta is the meta-discussion site for the Codidact community network and the Codidact software. Whether you have bug reports or feature requests, support questions or rule discussions that touch the whole network – this is the site for you.
Post History
GitHub issue: https://github.com/codidact/qpixel/issues/1577#issue-2958874420 In a Codidact community where I have not yet earned the "Participate Everywhere" ability, I am unable to comment...
#4: Post edited
by
Monica Cellio
·
2025-03-31T19:34:02Z (26 days ago)
#3: Post edited
by
trichoplax
·
2025-03-30T13:25:02Z (27 days ago)
Add link to GitHub issue
- In a Codidact community where I have not yet earned the "Participate Everywhere" ability, I am unable to comment except on my own posts and answers to my own posts. This is as intended.
- I attempted to post a comment in an existing comment thread on an answer to my own question on Electrical Engineering Meta (where I do not have "Participate Everywhere"). I expected this to work, because although I did not create the comment thread, I should be able to add comments to it since it is on an answer to my question.
- It appeared to fail. However, instead of a failure message through the user interface, I received a raw JSON response, which Firefox displays as a list of keys and values:
- > 
- Note that this is not a screenshot of the developer window. This is what is displayed to the user after pressing "Add reply". It's not a pop up window, it's the sole content of the page.
- In addition to not being how errors are generally presented to the user, the error is also incorrect, as the [comment was successfully posted](https://electrical.codidact.com/comments/thread/10500#comment-26317) (which I found out later when I visited the question page again).
- ---
- This is not just me. There has been [another report on Software Development Codidact](https://software.codidact.com/posts/293642).
- - GitHub issue: https://github.com/codidact/qpixel/issues/1577#issue-2958874420
- ---
- In a Codidact community where I have not yet earned the "Participate Everywhere" ability, I am unable to comment except on my own posts and answers to my own posts. This is as intended.
- I attempted to post a comment in an existing comment thread on an answer to my own question on Electrical Engineering Meta (where I do not have "Participate Everywhere"). I expected this to work, because although I did not create the comment thread, I should be able to add comments to it since it is on an answer to my question.
- It appeared to fail. However, instead of a failure message through the user interface, I received a raw JSON response, which Firefox displays as a list of keys and values:
- > 
- Note that this is not a screenshot of the developer window. This is what is displayed to the user after pressing "Add reply". It's not a pop up window, it's the sole content of the page.
- In addition to not being how errors are generally presented to the user, the error is also incorrect, as the [comment was successfully posted](https://electrical.codidact.com/comments/thread/10500#comment-26317) (which I found out later when I visited the question page again).
- ---
- This is not just me. There has been [another report on Software Development Codidact](https://software.codidact.com/posts/293642).
#2: Post edited
by
trichoplax
·
2025-03-30T13:08:34Z (27 days ago)
Link to report on Software Development Codidact
- In a Codidact community where I have not yet earned the "Participate Everywhere" ability, I am unable to comment except on my own posts and answers to my own posts. This is as intended.
- I attempted to post a comment in an existing comment thread on an answer to my own question on Electrical Engineering Meta (where I do not have "Participate Everywhere"). I expected this to work, because although I did not create the comment thread, I should be able to add comments to it since it is on an answer to my question.
- It appeared to fail. However, instead of a failure message through the user interface, I received a raw JSON response, which Firefox displays as a list of keys and values:
- > 
- Note that this is not a screenshot of the developer window. This is what is displayed to the user after pressing "Add reply". It's not a pop up window, it's the sole content of the page.
In addition to not being how errors are generally presented to the user, the error is also incorrect, as the [comment was successfully posted](https://electrical.codidact.com/comments/thread/10500#comment-26317) (which I found out later when I visited the question page again).
- In a Codidact community where I have not yet earned the "Participate Everywhere" ability, I am unable to comment except on my own posts and answers to my own posts. This is as intended.
- I attempted to post a comment in an existing comment thread on an answer to my own question on Electrical Engineering Meta (where I do not have "Participate Everywhere"). I expected this to work, because although I did not create the comment thread, I should be able to add comments to it since it is on an answer to my question.
- It appeared to fail. However, instead of a failure message through the user interface, I received a raw JSON response, which Firefox displays as a list of keys and values:
- > 
- Note that this is not a screenshot of the developer window. This is what is displayed to the user after pressing "Add reply". It's not a pop up window, it's the sole content of the page.
- In addition to not being how errors are generally presented to the user, the error is also incorrect, as the [comment was successfully posted](https://electrical.codidact.com/comments/thread/10500#comment-26317) (which I found out later when I visited the question page again).
- ---
- This is not just me. There has been [another report on Software Development Codidact](https://software.codidact.com/posts/293642).
#1: Initial revision
by
trichoplax
·
2025-01-13T02:10:47Z (3 months ago)
Incorrect raw JSON failure message on posting a comment
In a Codidact community where I have not yet earned the "Participate Everywhere" ability, I am unable to comment except on my own posts and answers to my own posts. This is as intended. I attempted to post a comment in an existing comment thread on an answer to my own question on Electrical Engineering Meta (where I do not have "Participate Everywhere"). I expected this to work, because although I did not create the comment thread, I should be able to add comments to it since it is on an answer to my question. It appeared to fail. However, instead of a failure message through the user interface, I received a raw JSON response, which Firefox displays as a list of keys and values: >  Note that this is not a screenshot of the developer window. This is what is displayed to the user after pressing "Add reply". It's not a pop up window, it's the sole content of the page. In addition to not being how errors are generally presented to the user, the error is also incorrect, as the [comment was successfully posted](https://electrical.codidact.com/comments/thread/10500#comment-26317) (which I found out later when I visited the question page again).