Welcome to Codidact Meta!
Codidact Meta is the meta-discussion site for the Codidact community network and the Codidact software. Whether you have bug reports or feature requests, support questions or rule discussions that touch the whole network – this is the site for you.
Post History
We need to figure out tags in the "Site Proposals" category. I noticed that some proposals were tagged "suggestion" and some "new-communities" and started to replace the former with the latter, an...
#6: Post edited
by
Michael
·
2024-02-16T21:32:39Z (9 months ago)
Let's make it a little more emphatic.
What should we do about tagging in Site Proposals?
- We need to figure out tags in the "Site Proposals" category. I noticed that some proposals were tagged "suggestion" and some "new-communities" and started to replace the former with the latter, and then I stopped and said "wait, *everything* here is a suggestion for a new community!".
- For technical reasons we need to have *some* tag right now, but what should the tag(s) there be? Adding a tag for launched communities makes sense, and maybe one for proposals we've agreed we're not going to do, but that doesn't help with the initial tagging.
- Or maybe everything is a status-something tag -- proposals start at status-proposed, and then we might retag to status-something-else as it moves through the process?
- Ideas?
Superseded by [the new Proposals site](https://meta.codidact.com/posts/288447). (I can't close this as superseded, maybe because the target is an article or maybe because it's in a different category?)
- We need to figure out tags in the "Site Proposals" category. I noticed that some proposals were tagged "suggestion" and some "new-communities" and started to replace the former with the latter, and then I stopped and said "wait, *everything* here is a suggestion for a new community!".
- For technical reasons we need to have *some* tag right now, but what should the tag(s) there be? Adding a tag for launched communities makes sense, and maybe one for proposals we've agreed we're not going to do, but that doesn't help with the initial tagging.
- Or maybe everything is a status-something tag -- proposals start at status-proposed, and then we might retag to status-something-else as it moves through the process?
- Ideas?
- ## Superseded by [the new Proposals site](https://meta.codidact.com/posts/288447).
- I can't close this question as superseded, maybe because the target is an article or maybe because it's in a different category.
#5: Post edited
by
Monica Cellio
·
2024-02-16T17:16:27Z (9 months ago)
- We need to figure out tags in the "Site Proposals" category. I noticed that some proposals were tagged "suggestion" and some "new-communities" and started to replace the former with the latter, and then I stopped and said "wait, *everything* here is a suggestion for a new community!".
- For technical reasons we need to have *some* tag right now, but what should the tag(s) there be? Adding a tag for launched communities makes sense, and maybe one for proposals we've agreed we're not going to do, but that doesn't help with the initial tagging.
- Or maybe everything is a status-something tag -- proposals start at status-proposed, and then we might retag to status-something-else as it moves through the process?
- Ideas?
- We need to figure out tags in the "Site Proposals" category. I noticed that some proposals were tagged "suggestion" and some "new-communities" and started to replace the former with the latter, and then I stopped and said "wait, *everything* here is a suggestion for a new community!".
- For technical reasons we need to have *some* tag right now, but what should the tag(s) there be? Adding a tag for launched communities makes sense, and maybe one for proposals we've agreed we're not going to do, but that doesn't help with the initial tagging.
- Or maybe everything is a status-something tag -- proposals start at status-proposed, and then we might retag to status-something-else as it moves through the process?
- Ideas?
- Superseded by [the new Proposals site](https://meta.codidact.com/posts/288447). (I can't close this as superseded, maybe because the target is an article or maybe because it's in a different category?)
#4: Post edited
by
Monica Cellio
·
2024-02-16T17:12:34Z (9 months ago)
we did resolve it, and then we replaced that category with the Proposals site, so this is all "overcome by events" now
#3: Post edited
by
meta user
·
2024-02-16T17:11:12Z (9 months ago)
added a required tag
What should we do about tagging in Site Proposals?
We need to figure out tags in the "Site Proposals" category. I noticed that some proposals were tagged "suggestion" and some "new-communities" and started to replace the former with the latter, and then I stopped and said "wait, *everything* here is a suggestion for a new community!". For technical reasons we need to have *some* tag right now, but what should the tag(s) there be? Adding a tag for launched communities makes sense, and maybe one for proposals we've agreed we're not going to do, but that doesn't help with the initial tagging. Or maybe everything is a status-something tag -- proposals start at status-proposed, and then we might retag to status-something-else as it moves through the process? Ideas?
#2: Post edited
by
Monica Cellio
·
2020-05-11T19:01:53Z (over 4 years ago)
- We need to figure out tags in the "Site Proposals" category. I noticed that some proposals were tagged "suggestion" and some "new-communities" and started to replace the former with the latter, and then I stopped and said "wait, *everything* here is a suggestion for a new community!".
- For technical reasons we need to have *some* tag right now, but what should the tag(s) there be? Adding a tag for launched communities makes sense, and maybe one for proposals we've agreed we're not going to do, but that doesn't help with the initial tagging.
- Ideas?
- We need to figure out tags in the "Site Proposals" category. I noticed that some proposals were tagged "suggestion" and some "new-communities" and started to replace the former with the latter, and then I stopped and said "wait, *everything* here is a suggestion for a new community!".
- For technical reasons we need to have *some* tag right now, but what should the tag(s) there be? Adding a tag for launched communities makes sense, and maybe one for proposals we've agreed we're not going to do, but that doesn't help with the initial tagging.
- Or maybe everything is a status-something tag -- proposals start at status-proposed, and then we might retag to status-something-else as it moves through the process?
- Ideas?
#1: Initial revision
by
Monica Cellio
·
2020-05-11T18:59:44Z (over 4 years ago)
We need to figure out tags in the "Site Proposals" category. I noticed that some proposals were tagged "suggestion" and some "new-communities" and started to replace the former with the latter, and then I stopped and said "wait, *everything* here is a suggestion for a new community!". For technical reasons we need to have *some* tag right now, but what should the tag(s) there be? Adding a tag for launched communities makes sense, and maybe one for proposals we've agreed we're not going to do, but that doesn't help with the initial tagging. Ideas?