Mark all as read

Welcome to Codidact Meta!

Codidact Meta is the meta-discussion site for the Codidact community network and the Codidact software. Whether you have bug reports or feature requests, support questions or rule discussions that touch the whole network – this is the site for you.

Multi-colored bookmarks


We'll want to have bookmarks, eventually. It would be nice to have bookmarks with some kind of categorization.

For example, favorites/bookmarks with different colors, because I want to come back to messages for different reasons.

  • Material for future reference.
  • Read later when I have time. Read one time, probably.
  • Answer later. I know the answer, but I can't write it right now, because I don't have the time.
  • Soft flag. Benefit of a doubt for new members. The quality of a question leaves a few things to be desired. The O.P. was prompted to improve the question. I want to give the O.P. time to bring the question up to standard. I want to check on this question later.

The feel and UX could be not much different from starring messages in gmail.

Why should this post be closed?


1 answer


I actually don't accept the premise here, or at least it's not obviously true to me. Specifically, I'm not sure there is that much of a benefit to implementing "bookmarking" at all. My immediate retort is that your browser (assuming it's any of the major ones) already implements bookmarking and has ways of organizing those bookmarks (and likely can support multi-colored bookmarks via an extension).

StackExchange supports bookmarks, but I basically never used it. My main use-case for it (which was clearly not the intended use-case) was keeping track of questions I had some interest in answering but didn't expect to answer in the near future. (Similar to your third use-case.) Even then, most of the time I just never looked at the list of bookmarked questions and so it really just was questions I wasn't going to get back to.

Bookmarks on StackExchange are public which I think is non-obvious and surprising to many SE users. It's also the wrong thing for many use-cases, e.g. every single one you list. Bookmarking (especially back when it was called "Favoriting") implies an endorsement of the question or, at least, some of its answers that is just not there for these use-cases.

So I assume you're imagining a private bookmarking system with maybe the option of making some public. If StackExchange bookmarks were private, and I used it for some of the purposes you list, I'd now be in the awkward position of needing to log into StackExchange just to get access to that information. Also, the bookmarks being private removes the necessity for a third-party to host this data.

I think public bookmarks a la StackExchange are just a mistake. I think using the browser's built-in bookmarking features (or some other bookmarking solution) is a strictly better solution than adding private bookmarks as a feature to the platform. The color coding you suggest here is just the beginning of a rabbit hole of embellishments on bookmarking that could be added. As the previous link demonstrates, there are entire applications built solely for organizing bookmarks.

1 comment

The other bookmarking solution at that link are for casual readers of blogs (I use Pocket from that list). Codidact patrons will have a broader range of interactions. There's a larger number of actions one may want defer. Nick Alexeev‭ 13 days ago

Sign up to answer this question »