Welcome to Codidact Meta!
Codidact Meta is the meta-discussion site for the Codidact community network and the Codidact software. Whether you have bug reports or feature requests, support questions or rule discussions that touch the whole network – this is the site for you.
Comments on I cannot understand the meaning of some downvotes
Parent
I cannot understand the meaning of some downvotes
In my opinion, downvoting some kinds of posts is meaningless.
For example, why should anyone downvote a bug report, like this post? If someone has the same problem, they can upvote the bug report; otherwise, they can skip it. Quite the contrary, I think bug report posts should be heavily upvoted to encourage other users to report bugs of the system.
Another example, why should anyone downvote a community proposal, like this post? If someone is interested in contributing to such a community, they can upvote the proposal; otherwise, they can skip it. Now, if I dislike a subject (or do not like to contribute to a proposed community) and see that there is some proposal covering the subject, then I should downvote the proposal?!
Votes on meta supposedly means "agree/don't agree". Which may make sense in some cases, not so much in other cases. I …
3y ago
In an ideal world, bug reports and support requests would be a separate stream from discussions and feature requests. W …
3y ago
why should anyone downvote a community proposal, like this post? Because they think it's a flawed proposal. That re …
3y ago
Post
In an ideal world, bug reports and support requests would be a separate stream from discussions and feature requests. We work with the tools we have, while also working to improve them. (A few people have reported software bugs on GitHub, which is fine too but not something we'd want to require.)
We've discussed a "discussion" post type, which would have different properties from Q&A. It depends on threaded comments (planned, not yet implemented).
It absolutely does make sense to vote on site proposals and feature requests. People who don't care one way or the other can ignore both, but people should be able to express "I think this is a bad idea". In the case of your site proposal, you propose to combine math with one of the several sciences that uses math, and have received feedback from people challenging that grouping. Some people clearly feel that your site proposal is confusing, arbitrary, or otherwise harmful, and have expressed that feeling through votes. Another site proposal, Medical Science, has received downvotes apparently because people are concerned with possibly handing out medical advice on the Internet to unknown patients. People should be able to downvote proposals they object to. Ideally they leave feedback explaining what the issues are, as has happened in these cases.
1 comment thread