Welcome to Codidact Meta!
Codidact Meta is the meta-discussion site for the Codidact community network and the Codidact software. Whether you have bug reports or feature requests, support questions or rule discussions that touch the whole network – this is the site for you.
Comments on What is "clutter" in the context of Codidact?
Parent
What is "clutter" in the context of Codidact?
It's common to hear comments about QA sites being "cluttered", "clogged", "spammed" etc. with types of questions that the commenter doesn't want.
What does this actually mean? Is there a definition of "clutter"?
I think of clutter primarily in terms of how it impacts community norms. If your programming language Q&A site has an …
7mo ago
> It's common to hear comments about QA sites being "cluttered", "clogged", "spammed" etc. Even disregarding adverti …
7mo ago
Clutter refers to the unwanted or uninteresting stuff you have to dispense with before getting to what you want. On a Q …
7mo ago
This is not an answer, but more detail about why it confuses me. I left it out of the question to keep it succinct. You …
7mo ago
Post
Clutter refers to the unwanted or uninteresting stuff you have to dispense with before getting to what you want. On a Q&A site, that usually means low quality questions. These questions clutter up the site so that when you look around for good questions the low quality ones get in the way and make the process less efficient and more annoying.
Clutter is also more than just in the way when you are looking for something good. It degrades the apparent value of the whole site when someone is first looking around. In that sense, it's not as much clutter as junk that lowers the average quality of whatever part of the site is investigated.
And no, good search doesn't really solve the problem. The search algorithm can be distracted by clutter just like a human. A search might identify 5 question out of 5000 that match your criteria, but several of those 5 could easily be clutter.
One thing we do to combat clutter is voting. Clutter would usually be voted down, while good content is voted up. Differentiating questions and answers by vote score does help. However, sometimes we don't want something else making decisions for us about what we want to see. Then clutter gets in the way again.
0 comment threads