Welcome to Codidact Meta!
Codidact Meta is the meta-discussion site for the Codidact community network and the Codidact software. Whether you have bug reports or feature requests, support questions or rule discussions that touch the whole network – this is the site for you.
Comments on Why do we have "General comments" threads?
Parent
Why do we have "General comments" threads?
Comments below posts are grouped into threads, each of which can have a meaningful name so several different conversations can happen in parallel with less risk of confusion.
However, sometimes the thread title is simply "General comments" which does not help the reader understand what the thread contains. Why does this sometimes happen?
History Originally, comments worked much as one may have seen Somewhere Else; but in mid-2021 the threaded comments f …
11mo ago
The "General comments" title is a left-over from earlier versions of the software that didn't have comment titles. When …
11mo ago
I'm one of the offenders, and the answer is quite simple: I often don't know what else to name it, even after several mi …
11mo ago
Post
I'm one of the offenders, and the answer is quite simple: I often don't know what else to name it, even after several minutes of hard thinking. I want commmenting to be a task of ease, not a task of complication.
In addition, there are many sorts of comments that don't actually fit very well in their own buckets, and are better grouped with other ones; these comments form the group of general responses, hence the name: "general comments". Just because we can have different buckets for every comment, doesn't mean we should.
One can always revisit the name of a comment thread later on, if the set of general comments actually turned out to have something not so general in common.
3 comment threads
3 comment threads