Welcome to Codidact Meta!
Codidact Meta is the meta-discussion site for the Codidact community network and the Codidact software. Whether you have bug reports or feature requests, support questions or rule discussions that touch the whole network – this is the site for you.
Comments on Why don't we just make communities for every launched stack?
Parent
Why don't we just make communities for every launched stack?
Rather than reinvent each community, why don't the admins just create a community for each subject that Stack launched a site for?
Such as statistics, interpersonal skills, workplace, law, philosophy ....
Because Codidact doesn't want to be a clone of SE but rather be its own thing, and that for good reasons. Of course, …
3y ago
As @Lundin stated in comments: > Because they have 100 or so of them and we don't want to create 100 ghost towns? …
3y ago
why don't the admin[s] just create a community for each subject that Stack launched a site for? Because content doesn …
3y ago
Post
why don't the admin[s] just create a community for each subject that Stack launched a site for?
Because content doesn't create a community. Engaged users do.
If sites here are just clones of elsewhere, then there is no point for a core group of users to be here. In fact, having content here be largely copies from elsewhere will actually drive those necessary core users away.
Even if new people happen to stumble on this site, all those attribution links will surely cause them to at least check out the other site. Once that happens, they are unlikely to come back. Why should they? All the activity and original copies of the content are Over There.
In case there is still any doubt, look at our experience here. We have 10 non-meta sites today. Of those, the three that heavily imported content from elsewhere (Writing, Outdoors, Scientific Speculation) are in the bottom 4 of activity and nearly dead.
The folks over at Writing are actually discussing deleting some of the imported content.
1 comment thread