Welcome to Codidact Meta!
Codidact Meta is the meta-discussion site for the Codidact community network and the Codidact software. Whether you have bug reports or feature requests, support questions or rule discussions that touch the whole network – this is the site for you.
Why is there a rep system in Codidact?
I had visited Codidact quite some time ago when it was still being built. At that time, there weren't many talks about having the reputation system built on this site.
Partly, The reason why Slack communities and Discord communities are so easy-going and helpful has something in common between them both - the lack of any actual rep points.
You don't need a number to show your expertise - your arguments should do that. Treating everyone on an even playing field produces a much more productive debate than any other measure.
I am going to be brutally honest here - I was initially interested because Codidact seemed something new, but now it's another StackExchange in the making.
The rep system is completely useless and negatively affects the flow of debate:
Your arguments should be your support in a constructive debate, not reputation
Trust Levels seem to be a better way (established by upvoted answers and the like) but showing a title rather than a flashy number.
Making it a rep game would lead to lower quality answers and questions as the primary aim would be points, not for spreading knowledge.
People who want to answer questions (and are knowledgable) really need no 'fake internet points' as an incentive - having a trust system would work pretty well giving them extra privileges, while not signifying that they are all-knowing.
Simply put, there is no amount of reasons or arguments that can offset an actual real-life example - StackOverflow has already become what it was always destined for, and now is the last chance for Codidact.
Either you have a smaller range of numbers (1-10) to denote their moderation powers, or you take trust levels. That would be the closest simulation to Slack and Discord while working far better than both by having a formal framework.
Please don't spell death for this forum!
We didn't set out to have a reputation stat, but because we started by adapting code that had it, we started out that wa …
Actually Codidact should support rep better than it does now. Most of the dislike of rep seems to come from a misunders …
Part of this question is about making Codidact more Like Slack and Discord, which are not even question and answer sites …
What is repo/reputation? Reputation is just number. Any user can know how active you are in Codidact by seeing your r …
I agree with the notion that reputation numbers cause more harm than good, at least in general and at least in the long …